Originally posted by NorCalSportsFan:
Cal14 - Re Aptos playing Bells
I believe Palma is replacing its Saint Francis or Carmel slot with Belarmine. Been trying to get Palma to try to get a Campolindo, Cardinal Newman (they talked last year) and Sutter game when it was though the CCS would go back to enrollments. Now it looks like Palma will have to schedule an out of section D1 power and win to get bowl consideration when only 420 students. Not sure who the other slot is.
Aptos as I mentioned above certainly deserved to be in the bowl for the reasons described. Sutter tried to schedule tougher competition, but just didn't work out. Novato hasn't been the same program as they have for several years though and El Cerrito was expected to fall some this season. Overall though Sutter showed enough to be picked. I think if Marin Catholic didn't lose to Justin Sienna and played so lose to Campo, Aptos would have been chosen. Sutter domination of Justin Sienna helped although margin of victory shouldn't be considered. Kind of a similar comparison to the Aptos win over St Ignatius. Overall Aptos had a stronger SOS, but it seems this comparison was weighted more than anything else and I agree that based on your assessment that Aptos should have been chosen. I think either team is deserving and snubbed may be harsh. The way teams are picked leaves to much subjectivity and it seems to promote in some ways to schedule to go undefeated and SOS can be used or not for or against a team. I think D3 in any event will be a good game. Socal D3 team should dominate whoever gets to the state bowl.