ADVERTISEMENT

CIF SJS Football Playoffs Selection Show

curious, which teams should be ranked above GB

ROcklin, one could argue jesuit... but that could've gone either way
In my opinion Jesuit, Rocklin due to head to head and league record.

I will just throw this against the wall. What if league records mattered for seeding, probably an awful idea but you get seeded on your enrollment then league record.

I get this would screw tough leagues so you would need to address some other weighting for SOS Or Alpha leagues. In this fantasy, many teams are seeded ahead of superior opponents and you open the bracket to 16, no byes. I'm sure the gate money would appease the CIF, the extra games for tough league opponents would be fun for the kids and the inferior teams get their starry eyed shot at hosting a home game and end of year banquet the same night.

Bonus, we get to screw the 🏀 coaches.
 
I agree that there needs to be a system where teams like Laguna Creek get in. It has been mentioned, but we should be promoting teams who are trying to build up their programs in some way. And Laguna Creek fits that bill.

That said, Granite Bay is a playoff level team. Yes they have one league win, but they also beat the champs from the Delta and the MEL.
Granite Bay is a playoff level team. I’m not questioning their ability as a team.

My issue is the system that places a 1-4 league team in the playoffs and not a 3-2 league team.

The CIF created and or approved these leagues. Laguna had a winning league record.
 
100% agree! I was speaking with a Lincoln supporter on the sidelines during the SM vs Lincoln game last Friday and we both agreed Edison should have been allowed to move to TCAL (as an Edison fan/coach shared they were denied with their request). But, the Lincoln supporter also suggested St. Mary’s be moved out of TCAL and there should be a formed Catholic league with St. Mary’s, De La Salle, Central Catholic, Jesuit, and BOD be the teams included. I shared that would be a good idea and it could be called the ECAL (East version of WCAL). But, I also suggested St. Mary’s return to the VOL league where Central Catholic is currently part of. Some strong teams like CC, Manteca, and Oakdale currently exist. I think the Lincoln guy was much frustrated with the losing streak. There was a time that Lincoln, Edison, and St. Mary’s would all three teams be very competitive, early 2000’s. He recalled as well. But, now he says it’s unfair and questioned what changed. I shared one reason for improvement was St. Mary’s having their own feeder program with the Junior Rams program. But, like De La Salle and Folsom, parents in the area want their kids to play for St. Mary’s because of the success it has had. Parents gravitate to sending their kids to schools where there is success and want to be a part of it. To be honest, when I sent my kids to St. Mary’s starting in 2003, I had no clue about their football program and really didn’t care. I sent my sons to St. Mary’s because of academics and because of enriching their Catholic faith, sports was a lower priority. My eldest son was actually aiming to join the St. Mary’s water polo team because his swim coach pre-high school was a St. Mary’s alumnus and thought my son would be playing varsity water polo as a freshman. He did not pursue water polo mainly because of logistics. He would have to practice at UOP and would need transportation. Also, everyone was saying if you want to get to know the fellow freshman boys, sign up for football. Also, he was having a good time/experience playing for the South Stockton Vikings, where another player from that team joined him at St. Mary’s. But, now I believe it has been the success at St. Mary’s that has done its own recruiting (not coaches like many think). Maybe it’s fallen it a slight bit at DLS because coaching has changed, especially with the retirement of Terry Eidson (completing the coaching transition)? But, many think Covid has attributed to the decline due to tuition cost and economy. Even St. Mary’s enrollment is down quite a bit due to tuition cost and economy. When my sons were attending SM, they had around 1200 enrollment. Now it’s around 700-800 students. Also, how much more time before Coach Franks retires? What happens when he does retire? Coach Tony Franks is a SM alumnus and has been their head coach since my eldest son attended the school. So, maybe St. Mary’s may be soon on the decline. At least the schools such as Edison and Lincoln hope so. So, maybe no need to kick SM out of TCAL, just yet. Lol.

The SJS (schools, families, coaches, section leaders) made a big fuss about the private schools years ago. They couldn’t handle a league with St. Mary’s, Jesuit, Christian Brothers, Capital Christian, and Central Catholic…. People would accuse them of “recruiting” and taking all of the best players…

These games would bring in record setting $$$ and would become “the best league in NorCal” hahahahahaha

Every league game would be a Holy Bowl! Lol
 
  • Haha
Reactions: bulldogmgc
The SJS (schools, families, coaches, section leaders) made a big fuss about the private schools years ago. They couldn’t handle a league with St. Mary’s, Jesuit, Christian Brothers, Capital Christian, and Central Catholic…. People would accuse them of “recruiting” and taking all of the best players…

These games would bring in record setting $$$ and would become “the best league in NorCal” hahahahahaha

Every league game would be a Holy Bowl! Lol
None of the best players are going to privates in the SJS. Just the reality.

They generally get the "2nd tier kids."

Educationally- The SFL schools are a notch above a private....and they are free. :)
 
  • Haha
Reactions: bulldogmgc
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT