Originally posted by ThunderRam:
In response to the question posed about where Folsom ranks all time in the SJS, I think that's difficult to judge. It's easy to look at it and say they are #1 now because they will have gone 16-0 with, possibly, 16 running clocks and nobody has accomplished that before. Well, there are many things that need to be considered.
First, teams like Cordova (76/85), Grant Union (96/06), Nevada Union (93), Elk Grove (97/98), etc. didn't the opportunity to play more than 14 games and go to Regionals or State.
Secondly, you have to consider the depth in the section at the time. IMO, there weren't many really good teams in the Section this season. For example, Grant Union came into last night's game as undefeated section champs. They had only accomplished that feat twice before, which would indicate that this is one of their best teams ever. However, that is not the case. It is easily argued that -- of their 7 section title winning teams -- this team ranks 4th at best (behind 1996, 2006, 2008). And then there were non-section winners in 1997, 1998, 2009, and 2010 that had far more blue chip talent (Donte Stallworth, Onterrio Smith, Shaq Thompson, Vili Moala, James Sample, etc). Those teams happened to play in a year where the section had more great teams.
While I do think this current Folsom team is among the all-time greats, I think it's debatable that it's even Folsom's best team. Their 2010 team played in a year where the section was deeper and they were more battle tested. Their 2009 team was essentially the same roster as 2010, but they lost in the semi finals to another truly good team. IMO, the 2009 season was the deepest and best I've seen - specifically in the D2 bracket. Had that 2009 team played this year in place of the current team, I think they would have won the section too.
Having said all that, I definitely place this Folsom team in the top 5 best SJS teams from 1976 to current. I never saw Cordova '76 (who is the only area team to win a National title), but I did see all the other teams mentioned and I couldn't rank this Bulldogs team above them.
This post was edited on 12/13 7:44 PM by ThunderRam