Don't worry. I know about the Varsity. If I don't see improvement the next three seasons, then there has to be big-time changes on the Admin end.
.
I don't think the SHC admin should wait another
3 years?! to see if they should keep going with Peralta. As I said on this board in years past with Riordan and their crap coaches they needed to cut their losses and move on, not double down on a bad investment. If he truly wants the best for his alma mater he should resign and maybe take over the Frosh team as I know he is liked by the administration and staff. His stubbornness and refusal to adapt to his personnel season after season has been a great disservice to his players and the alums/parents.
With the new CCS playoff format and how the points and seeding are determined (the WCAL is no longer given A+ league designation) it may be best for SHC to remove itself from the league for Football and go to Independent status once again. Hopefully they can petition the CCS to allow them to still be eligible for the A league "Open" division playoffs. I say this for the following reasons:
1. There is precedent. SHC left the WCAL in the 1980's after years of being non-competitive in the sport. They were gone for nearly 20 years and returned with some success the first season back in 2008 (went 4-3 in league). That year only 3 teams had a positive point differentials indicating a down year in the WCAL. SH had a -47 point differential that season. This year 5 teams have a positive point differential indicating a strong year for the league. In fact, this season is the highest rating the WCAL has had in 13 years of CalPreps league ratings.
They haven't beaten a non-SF league team since 2008. Irish Cheers I'm sure can say if they were more competitive before leaving in the 80's than they are now. I don't quite remember but I feel as if they were actually a bit more competitive then they are now.
2. The alumni and school moral were greater during the Independent years. Irish Cheers himself touts the undefeated teams during that era as a source of pride and accomplishment. Seeing the mostly empty stands the past 3 seasons hasn't been a welcomed sight.
3. A maximum of 6 teams per league can qualify for the CCS open playoffs (4 automatic and 2 at large bids based on power points) and thus are eligible for regional and state games. This makes it extremely difficult for SHC to ever make the playoffs if they are to stay in the WCAL. Not only would they have to come in 6th place but they would have to get enough wins throughout the season to qualify for an at large bid based on points. For example 2 league wins and a 6th place finish might not be enough to qualify.
4. Removing SHC from the league would allow for better seeding for the WCAL schools. An extra game to schedule against another A league opponent who potentially could become a league champion would add CCS points and boost seeding rather than playing SHC.
In 20 WCAL games as Head Coach at SHC Peralta's teams have averaged 9 PPG and given up 34 PPG. It is time to move on. Enough is enough.