I think this reflects small schools with limited #'s of high end athletes loading up on the offensive side of the ball and playing the rest of their guys on D. I get the risk in not platooning but Carmel's D line averages about 190lbs and the O Line around 230. Speaking from my experience in watching them, they get outmanned on D while their beat athletes stay fresh on the sidelines. That's great if you can score at will, but yesterday showed that sometimes even that isn't enough.