Whitney has barely been .500 8 of the last 13 years playing teams that are supposedly inferior to the entire SFL.
In what world is 84-57 (.596) considered barely over .500? And that includes a terrible 1-9 in 2007 and 0-4 this season.
They finished over .500 in 9 of their 12 seasons coming into 2018.
71-70 or even 74-67 would be considered barely over .500. But 27 games over .500 doesn't qualify as such.
You're stretching the truth.
Absolutely, considering that the statement is being made 1 game into their 1st ever season in the league.
I just don't believe in handing something to somebody that they haven't yet earned. Woodcreek earned their perception over 22 seasons. Whitney has a long way to go before they prove to be in over their heads in this league -- let alone at Woodcreek's level.
If they had been in the SFL, they would have been UNDER .500 every year just like Woodcreek.
"If ifs and buts were candy and nuts, we'd all have a merry Christmas."
You're just speculating. Maybe they would have, maybe they wouldn't have. They did have a couple pretty good teams that won section titles, so who knows how those teams would have performed in an SFL that wasn't near as deep as it is now.
While I tend to agree with you that they still would have been a cellar dweller most of their years, it's simply not fair to guess and state it as fact. I'm no Whitney fan, but I'm prepared to let them create their own legacy -- good or bad. In other words, let it play out first.
It's like Utah State joining the Pac 12.
This is a bad comparison. Utah State is at a disadvantage when it comes to recruiting against other PAC-12 schools. Therefore they can't build the same kinds of teams.
But in the world of HS sports where schools can't recruit and Whitney can draw kids from the same areas as Rocklin, Woodcreek, Lincoln, Del Oro, Roseville and Granite Bay -- they have just as good a shot as anyone.
What actually set Whitney back recently was the coaching drama that lost them Paul Doherty. If he was still at the helm, they'd likely be competing much better than they are.