The only thing that stays constant on this board are Riordan and SHC alums/supporters touting how good each is and the demise of each school. Honestly, if it wasnt for the four or five divisions in sectionals, neither school (along with SI) would see much action beyond league. Before 1980 only the champions of each league would play beyond league, and I dont see either school (including the Cats) doing that in recent history.
Look the Elephant in room with transfers is this:
the AAU circuit for basketball has players and parents dreaming beyond high school.
Far are the days when athletic kids (particularly basketball, to now some extent baseball) picked a school for school itself. There is very little allegiance to one's alma mater like their was before the 90s. These kids play year around now and with kids from rival schools, and their parents talk to each other constantly. Where Johnny will fit in, and in what program, is always part of the conversation.
Being true to your school goes as far as what Johnny and his parents see as the best avenue to get looks. Old school parents expected their kids to finish at one school. With the "Jones' " moving from school to school, a lot of parents are thinking why not me - whatever makes the kid and parent "happy".
I too attended one of the "Unholy Trinity". Some sports we were good at, others we were not. but we learned from both and didnt expect a quick fix would make it all better - it rarely, if ever, does. I cant think of a single kid who transferred to play at another rival school,
Being that said, exhale and enjoy what is left of summer.
Look the Elephant in room with transfers is this:
the AAU circuit for basketball has players and parents dreaming beyond high school.
Far are the days when athletic kids (particularly basketball, to now some extent baseball) picked a school for school itself. There is very little allegiance to one's alma mater like their was before the 90s. These kids play year around now and with kids from rival schools, and their parents talk to each other constantly. Where Johnny will fit in, and in what program, is always part of the conversation.
Being true to your school goes as far as what Johnny and his parents see as the best avenue to get looks. Old school parents expected their kids to finish at one school. With the "Jones' " moving from school to school, a lot of parents are thinking why not me - whatever makes the kid and parent "happy".
I too attended one of the "Unholy Trinity". Some sports we were good at, others we were not. but we learned from both and didnt expect a quick fix would make it all better - it rarely, if ever, does. I cant think of a single kid who transferred to play at another rival school,
Being that said, exhale and enjoy what is left of summer.
Last edited: