A couple of notes:
Walsh is not perfect. Far from it. He would readily admit that. But he did assume control of a moribund Serra program in 2001 (his first head coaching job) and, within one year, brought it to a co-WCAL title with Valley Christian (which joined the league in 2002). Those two programs broke the St. Francis/Bellarmine stranglehold on the league championship. That 2001 co-crown was Serra's first since 1972. Talk about a drought.
Walsh also was primarily responsible for a truncated prep football "season" in the spring of 2021. Other sports benefited as well. Teens got back on the field and in the gym. His lobbying and public relations work via the media and politicians was outstanding. He became the face of California prep athletics, for good or ill.
He hasn't been avoiding tough schedules. His 2024 log is a killer _ Folsom, DLS and Bosco all in a row. Ouch. Combined with the typical WCAL sked, Serra's 2024 opponents add up to the most difficult since the school first fielded a varsity football unit in 1946. So, regardless of his expertise with X's and O's, he hasn't been ducking challenges.
On a different front, Walsh has become, arguably, Serra's (and the WCAL's) most important spokesman and recognizable figure. That can indeed rub some folks the wrong way. The Serra football program now represents about 27 percent of the school's total enrollment. You can view that in both positive and negative ways.
Some associated with the San Mateo school fret that it is viewed by the public as a "jock" enterprise. Football is the primary reason. Walsh's thriving youth sports business is another source of an undercurrent of discontent in some quarters. It's been too successful in some ways at this point,
In sum, Walsh is seen somehow as a Jekyll/Hyde figure by a lot of people. He's terrific and less-so at the same time. There's a lot more to this guy than meets the casual eye. He has his critics. He also has supporters. He's a target. That's the price of success, though limited to Northern California (2-6 vs. SoCal units), as if that is now a failing. How much longer will he stay coaching at Serra? It's not clear. But speculation is growing.
A footnote: With 17 of 22 starters (most of whom were heavy-duty contributors to a 36-1 record vs NorCal teams over the last three campaigns) gone from Serra's stellar 2023 team, arguably the best in school history, naysayers are looking forward to 2024 as the Padres re-tool with a young group of key newcomers (more than a dozen sophs may be on the varsity on opening night in Folsom). There will be defeats, some of them, perhaps, ugly. A 6-4 or 5-5 mark is likely. Let the catcalls commence.