ADVERTISEMENT

NCS post-season bracketing: What I understand

ClayK

Hall of Famer
Jun 25, 2001
8,657
1,746
113
It's a two-part process:

1) MaxPreps rankings will determine what teams are placed in what bracket -- regardless of the margins involved. At this moment, for example, Justin-Siena has a strength rating of 23.34, putting them sixth in the section and in the Open. Clayton Valley Charter's 23.32 puts them seventh and in Division 1.

Acording to what I know, that would be set in stone, even if CVC had played Justin-Siena and won by 30.

2) Once the brackets are set, the committee can seed as it sees fit. So at that point, head-to-head and other factors can come into play. Obviously, the MaxPreps algorithm will still have a very strong say, but adjustments can be made.

Given the big difference between being 16 in one division and 1 in the next lowest, I'm OK with the decision being by the numbers rather than a committee's subjectivity. Of course it won't be perfect, but no system is.

Note that 102 teams can be fit into the NCS brackets out of the 153 schools in the section. One question I don't know the answer to: If, say, only 96 teams qualify, or want to be in, which brackets absorb the six byes? Does Division VI then go with 10? Or does each division have only 15 teams?

The latest section rankings can be found at:

 
  • Like
Reactions: northbaybbguru
So Clay - a few questions.

1) Top 6 in the rankings will be assigned to the Open Division. Then the next 16 (ranked 7-22) go D1, the next 16 (ranked 23-38) to D2, and so on. --- BUT teams can only move up/down TWO divisions if not assigned to the Open Division.
So a team like Salesian (D4) currently ranked in NCS at #10 would be the #1 seed in D2? Is that correct?
St. Bernard (D5), currently NCS ranked #12, would be the #1 seed in D3? Is that correct?

2) Will the committee look at a team - say TEAM A - that is ranked ahead of another team - say TEAM B - in MaxPreps but Team A finishes behind Team B in league play - will Team A be seeded via MaxPreps ranking or will the committee make adjustments, taking into account league finishes or is overall schedule weighted more?

3) Will a team have any say on how many divisions they move up or down or is that the sole discretion of the seeding committee? So will any team be allowed to stay in their assigned division or move up/down only one division versus the max two?

4) What happens to the NorCal auto bids? All SIX Open teams get auto bids while D1, D2, and D3 only get 2 while the other divisions (D4-6) get 4 bids. Do all the Norcal bids remain the same? Any discussion on awarding the auto bids differently?
 
So Clay - a few questions.

1) Top 6 in the rankings will be assigned to the Open Division. Then the next 16 (ranked 7-22) go D1, the next 16 (ranked 23-38) to D2, and so on. --- BUT teams can only move up/down TWO divisions if not assigned to the Open Division.
So a team like Salesian (D4) currently ranked in NCS at #10 would be the #1 seed in D2? Is that correct?
St. Bernard (D5), currently NCS ranked #12, would be the #1 seed in D3? Is that correct?

2) Will the committee look at a team - say TEAM A - that is ranked ahead of another team - say TEAM B - in MaxPreps but Team A finishes behind Team B in league play - will Team A be seeded via MaxPreps ranking or will the committee make adjustments, taking into account league finishes or is overall schedule weighted more?

3) Will a team have any say on how many divisions they move up or down or is that the sole discretion of the seeding committee? So will any team be allowed to stay in their assigned division or move up/down only one division versus the max two?

4) What happens to the NorCal auto bids? All SIX Open teams get auto bids while D1, D2, and D3 only get 2 while the other divisions (D4-6) get 4 bids. Do all the Norcal bids remain the same? Any discussion on awarding the auto bids differently?
In Football....in response to question 2..

The Open took both Marin Catholic and Cardinal Newman from the same league. CN was rated as #4 in Max Preps while Marin was #5. Marin Catholic beat CN in league play h2h and finished ahead of CN. The committee flip floped the 2 in the Open puting MC at 4 and CN as 5.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT